You wouldn’t know this from about 70 % of the films about him, however for almost all of his existence, Batman has by no means been a loner. Invoice Finger and Bob Kane created Batman in 1939’s Detective Comics #27, and within the 80-plus years we’ve gotten Batman tales, he was solely actually alone for one; by 1940’s Detective Comics #38, Robin was born. Eleven comedian books: That’s what number of had been revealed earlier than Batman’s creators determined to provide him a sidekick.

Whereas there have been many comedian books that featured the Dark Knight flying solo, each one in all them did so with a quickly rising forged of caped heroes becoming a member of Batman’s campaign within the background, both in comics or Saturday morning cartoons. After a sure level, it seems like these films are much less Bruce Wayne and extra Drake, hiding a toddler. The kid is Robin. All of them.

If there’s a serious flaw to The Batman, it’s that it’s largely a remix of the acquainted. It’s an extremely trendy and excellent reconsideration of what got here earlier than, however it’s a rehash nonetheless. The explanation for that is easy: Many of the concepts about Batman nonetheless unexplored on-screen solely come into play if you encompass him with different characters: A Robin (any Robin), Batgirl (any Batgirl), Batwoman, Batwing, Nightwing, the Huntress, the Sign, Red Hood, Azrael, and in a single excellent Detective Comics run written by James Tynion IV, Clayface. It’s frankly weird {that a} main film studio, in a Hollywood atmosphere finest described as “the tulip craze, however for IP,” is leaving a lot franchise gold on the desk as a result of unusual, ahistorical assertion that Batman is a solo act.

A part of this can be a holdover from a extra insecure period the place comics evangelists felt the necessity to relentlessly advocate that the medium was not only for youngsters anymore. The Nineteen Eighties performed host to some genuinely revolutionary comics, and the expansion of a fan notion of Batman as a extra “actual world” hero attributable to his lack of conventional superpowers. Batman grew to become the avatar for the Pondering Man’s (emphasis on Man) superhero. It’s price remembering, nonetheless, that outdoors of comedian fandom, the typical individual’s touchstone for Batman was nonetheless Adam West. Batman has at all times contained multitudes.

Trendy Film Batman, nonetheless, has not, and that is arguably attributable to filmmakers’ reticence to deliver on the Bat-family past Joel Schumacher casting Chris O’Donnell in Batman Endlessly and Batman & Robin (The latter additionally featured Alicia Silvestone as Batgirl). Very like post-Adam West Batman comics, post-Schumacher Batman is most clearly outlined by a want to maneuver away from a blockbuster Batman deemed too toyetic and infantile, and, sarcastically, it’s achieved by related means: excising Robin, the scapegoat for kiddie Batman, as a result of he’s typically portrayed as a toddler. (For extra on the cyclical nature of Batman fandom, try Glen Weldon’s glorious e book The Caped Campaign.)

Picture: Chuck Dixon, Tom Grummett/DC Comics

That is slim pondering. Robin — and your complete Bat-family — is the reply to all these ponderous questions that crop up round Bat-films about whether or not or not Batman’s campaign is efficient or worthwhile or attaining something. The Bat-family is how Bruce Wayne’s singular mission can tackle a extra complicated, human form, with characters which are raised underneath it and push towards it and interpret it otherwise.

Batgirl and Batwoman begin off as impartial actors impressed by Batman’s campaign, every with their very own motivations and subtly totally different ethical traces. The assorted younger males who’ve been Robin are all fixed litmus assessments for whether or not or not the thought of Batman is working: Has he made Gotham a protected sufficient place to ship this younger man out after him? Has bringing one other of Gotham’s misplaced youngsters underneath his wing made their lives higher than his? Typically, the reply is sure — and Batman’s best tragedies are sometimes when the reply is not any.

There’s additionally an odd facet impact to the Bat-family’s absence in movie: It makes Batman’s solely counterpoints villains, wealthy individuals, cops, and his personal workers, direct representations of the failed establishments that necessitate Batman’s existence or, like Lucius Fox, individuals paid to maintain him flush with toys. With out different bat-people round him, Batman frankly appears deranged, and the world should warp round him to prop up the assertion that he’s not being ridiculous.

Picture: Warner Bros. Footage

On some stage, fashionable Bat-films perceive this. Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy in the end grew to become about Harvey Dent as a lot because it was about Batman, a symbolic pressure for good that would clear up Gotham throughout the system with out the necessity for masked justice — and ended with a extra optimistic “Robin” in place to imagine the cowl if wanted. Ben Affleck’s late-career Batman is haunted by the lack of an unseen Robin, and his arc throughout two crossover movies is one the place he realizes that loss has turned him bitter, and he wants others to maintain him centered on hope.

A lot of recent Batman cinema is devoted to promoting audiences on the fiction that the character sells to criminals: That he’s a bizarre creature of the night time, a boogeyman you don’t need to ever actually see. Maybe this is the reason tiresome arguments persist about why doesn’t Bruce Wayne simply give cash to charity as an alternative, or put his appreciable assets in the direction of one thing aside from customized bat-themed ninja gear. There’s a want for a richer world the place being Batman does one thing to Gotham Metropolis aside from encourage an allergic rash of carnival-themed madmen — a renewable useful resource that can by no means run dry, as a result of Batman is a personality that exists to battle such madmen.

That is irritating as a result of the reply to “does Batman make a distinction” is there, and has at all times been there from the beginning, for anybody who cares to look. Regardless of the lack of his household, Batman turns into courageous sufficient to construct a brand new one. Then that household builds a greater Batman: One which isn’t restricted to only one man, or the tales informed about him.